I love Script Ohio, I can not explain how much I appreciate dotting the “i”, but let’s be real. That iteration of marching band is your grandfather’s marching band. That is military inspired, European descended, practical marching band. American marching band shouldn’t be practical. So I hail Grambling and Southern Universities the most American marching bands in America.
I became aware of the Bayou Classic, and the more culturally significant Battle of the Bands around 1995 and I would say it forever made me covet my new standard of marching band bliss. Like I said, I totally get the Big-10 model marching band. It serves a purpose, but does it serve the purpose most Americans are looking for; to go totally freaking nuts at halftime. I don’t think so. I know that there are traditions that can not be replaced like Script Ohio, and the “World’s Largest Bass Drum,” and the faux Trojan armor of USC. I can concede that we are a nation that was “birthed” (in some people’s eyes) from the cultural stew of Western Europe, but I find that (a) misleading, and (b) incredibly dull. I appreciate the musical styling of a well versed marching band, but not as much as I like seeing a bunch of 18-22 year old kids go bananas having fun and playing music that is actually culturally significant to there audience.
I will leave the stodgy institutions of the bulk of this nation to uphold their traditions but as for me, I want to see high knee marching-pop music playing-drum major back-bending-head bobbing-cape wearing- splits doing-marching bands that still march glockenspiels… and a little character. After all what is more American than taking an accepted art form and molding into something that anyone can take something out of. This was a nation born from the hard work of “common men,” let’s start acting like it.

